Beyond EBITDA: The Definitive Scorecard for Measuring Your COO’s Impact in Year One

A sleek bullseye target where the innermost ring is clearly labeled "EBITDA" (or a dollar sign), but the subsequent, larger, and more dynamic rings are filled with icons or abstract representations of other critical KPIs (e.g., gears for process, people silhouettes for team, microchips for tech).

Hiring a new Chief Operating Officer (COO) is a significant milestone. But once the offer is accepted and the onboarding begins, the real question becomes: How do you measure their impact—especially in the first year? While EBITDA and cost savings are often the go-to metrics, they only tell part of the story.

At JRG Partners, we work closely with boards and executive teams to develop clear, strategic scorecards for COO evaluation—comprehensive frameworks that move beyond basic financials to capture the full scope of a COO’s influence.

Why EBITDA Alone Isn’t Enough

EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization) is a useful snapshot of financial performance, but it misses early, foundational wins that a new COO often delivers—like building scalable processes, upgrading talent, or implementing tech systems.

The COO of today is more than a cost controller—they’re an orchestrator of transformation. Measuring their impact requires KPIs that reflect both operational efficiency and strategic progress.

The Year-One COO Scorecard: What to Track Beyond EBITDA

Below are five essential categories—and specific KPIs—that form a balanced, actionable scorecard for evaluating your COO’s first-year performance.

1. Process Improvement and Operational Efficiency

Strong COOs streamline operations and eliminate bottlenecks. In year one, track:

  • Cycle time reductions (e.g., order-to-delivery, procurement-to-payment)
  • Error or defect rate improvement in critical workflows
  • Operating cost per unit (by region, function, or product line)
  • Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) implementation across departments

Why it matters: These early wins set the foundation for long-term scalability.

2. Team Leadership and Organizational Development

Operations can’t run without people. Evaluate how your COO is building the right leadership bench:

  • Leadership turnover rate in key operational roles
  • Internal promotion rate within the operations team
  • Employee engagement scores or retention in COO-led functions
  • Hiring velocity and quality for mission-critical positions

Why it matters: Great COOs know that systems fail when teams fail—people strategy is part of their mandate.

3. Technology Adoption and Digital Enablement

A subtle, glowing overlay of digital circuits or data streams integrated into a corporate environment or a human figure's hand interacting with a screen showing progress.

A modern COO must drive digital transformation that enhances efficiency, visibility, and decision-making.

  • System implementations delivered on time/on budget (ERP, supply chain platforms, automation tools)
  • Real-time dashboard adoption by leadership teams
  • Reduction in manual processes or spreadsheet dependency
  • IT and Ops alignment on digital roadmap milestones

Why it matters: Technology is not optional—it’s the backbone of agile, responsive operations.

4. Strategic Project Execution

Is your COO delivering on the big bets? Whether it’s expanding to new markets or integrating acquisitions, track:

  • Milestone completion on strategic initiatives
  • Budget adherence for major operational projects
  • Cross-functional collaboration scores (as measured by peer feedback)
  • Post-project performance improvements (e.g., cost savings, time to value)

Why it matters: Strategic execution is where the COO proves they’re not just tactical—but transformative.

5. Cultural and Cross-Functional Alignment

COOs sit at the intersection of departments. Their ability to build alignment across silos is critical.

  • Net Promoter Score (NPS) from peers in Sales, Product, Finance
  • Participation in cross-functional planning initiatives
  • Operational communication cadence (e.g., weekly huddles, KPI reviews)
  • Cultural integration success after M&A or restructuring

Why it matters: Operational effectiveness doesn’t live in isolation—it thrives in alignment.

Final Thoughts: Look for Momentum, Not Perfection

Your COO’s first year is not about flawless execution—it’s about creating momentum across systems, people, and strategy. The right scorecard will give you a clear view of their progress while aligning the rest of the leadership team on shared expectations.

At JRG Partners, we help organizations not only find COOs who can thrive in this environment—but also define the performance frameworks that support and measure their success.

Let’s Define What Success Looks Like—for You

Whether you’ve just hired a COO or are planning your next executive move, JRG Partners is your strategic partner in defining operational excellence from day one.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *